Foundations of Semantics I: Truth-conditions, entailment and logic Rick Nouwen j R.W.F.Nouwen@uu.nl February/March 2011, Gent 1Meaning There can be no simple answer to the question of what the meaning of a sentence is. /Filter /FlateDecode presupposes Peter smoked before. #l��Ţ���J��i��pG_�^̺���Ӏ.�0�h����j���eK�����̆�W���y���I��w�(Ϙ�=m��F�M�\Q�;2�7�-����%Uk�pK�����o"�;�ۺ4�mA���w!�p�� ��W��=���%P^���:�`B��0�E��qx@���?�8�eo���zsl6� ��CK ����p�ZF+���~�}��a�ҷ��E�FW��}[Vs �h+�[K��bl$�v�Z�A]��$���g�?���ei��&e��G�3�i�Y This principle is also called Frege's principle, because Gottlob Frege is widely credited for the first modern formulation of it. The exercise is in the section labeled "Exercise". assistant checks all the reasoning and a monad-based dynamic semantics deals with Montague-style semantics, and references (anaphora). presupposes Emily has been to … Review: Compositional semantics Today: Some syntactic and semantic assumptions and background. File 7.0 What Is Pragmatics? 2. Outline Principle of compositionality Semantic inference First-order logic Lambda calculus 2. (ii) a proper name? [We will ignore the existential quantifier ∃ in this exercise… Nothing close to a complete compositional semantics for English is known; not least because nothing close to a complete meaning representation is known. The Principle of Semantic Compositionality (sometimes called ‘Frege's Principle’) is the principle that the meaning of a (syntactically complex) whole is a function only of the meanings of its (syntactic) parts together with the manner in which these parts were combined. Exercise: Compositional Semantics These are some notes for this homework exercise. Summarizing Sense vs denotation Sense: a meaning or definition. *9�r Closed book Question types: ... Review and redo the exercises we did in class Learn the definitions of all the technical terms (most of them are in bold or are the titles of slides) The course is designed as an undergraduate-level introduction to truth-conditional, compositional semantics for students with no or little formal background and has been taught at NYU and UConn. ��z����,�)��"�b���@�K"�2AU,�@�u~�w�o This book provides an introduction to compositional semantics and to the syntax/semantics interface. Someone who doesn't know English will searc… Exercise Finish the derivation for the underspecified representation of Every student took a course. Once the meaningful lexical items are taken away—"Socrates" and "man"—what is left is the pseudo-sentence, "S was a M". L100: Lecture 7, Compositional semantics Typing in compositional semantics Typing I Semantic typing ensures that semantic expressions are consistent. Midterm Thursday, Nov 9, in class, 80 min. Semanticscan be defined as "the study of the meaning of morphemes, words, phrases and sentences." Nothing close to a complete compositional semantics for English is known; not least because nothing close to a complete meaning representation is known. What type of value is the extension of (i) a sentence? At the introductory level, three subtopics are covered: lexical semantics: relationships between words; phrasal semantics: relationships between sentences; compositional semantics: the meaning of sentences within the context of other sentences. File 6.0 What Is Semantics? It is rooted within the tradition of model theoretic semantics, and develops an explicit fragment of both the syntax and semantics of a rich portion of English. I understand the underlying structure of what type a certain type of phrase is ( i.e., proper names are , verbs can be , >, or >>.This seems to follow a straightforward pattern of having a set rule as to what type can be the input and what is the output. Formal Semantics, Lecture 11 Barbara H. Partee, MGU May 22, 2009 p. 4 MGU0911.doc 4 semantics of questions quite differently. Semantics 3. Dr. Elizabeth Coppock Compositional Semantics coppock@phil.hhu.de Heinrich Heine University Nov. 9, 2011 Winter Semester 2011/12 Model Answers to Problem Set 3 Reading: Heim and Kratzer, ch. Semantics, the study of meaning, is a core subfield of linguistics, a ... precise, compositional, model-theoretic account of semantics, us- ... to ask questions and solve exercises) and for self-study. Exercise: Identify the semantic type of beautiful in the following sentences: (12)a.Jenny is a beautiful girl. �P�,@R���l����է+�s�+` ,���(��fw���l�� Fz�ݰt��`)�z��oW��q Not everything is compositional. ��A�z�s��hrcH(���� �0�j�I���p,r�3�SQ�hV�Ex�9֗x�`\��1����C' K]z�MXə��}�H=��>�L'�m?�B��F���d�s)�������iO,Ē��/�c9&�1�1� 1I���}�m���Ø���(�d��?����a1����&\m���=��� ����ZB���l�;F�����p��.�ڧ���w1!��x��8/�o-B�ztGw��������敌͑�� �v���\�/�0ʳ�{���,�LH'�MOt�ML�lx�aW��#�dі�I�O&�g;�6K|y�O)J~%`�665�5�z��-����U7�q�?BI�P&��ѓ��p`i����0�t����8��72����G e.g., chase0(dog0(k)) is ill-formed. Compositional Semantics: phrase and sentence meaning Semantics and Syntax Compositional semantics is the study of meaning in the context of phrasal or syntactic structure. assistant checks all the reasoning and a monad-based dynamic semantics deals with Montague-style semantics, and references (anaphora). Here are some more examples for you to translate in a similar fashion. It is rooted within the tradition of model theoretic semantics, and develops an explicit fragment of both the syntax and semantics of a rich portion of English. (2.4) Dana saw … Basic structure in classic Montague grammar: (1) Syntactic categories and semantic “types”: … Chapter 6: Semantics. Syntactic Rule n: If α is an expression of category A and β is an expression of category B, then Fi(α,β) is an expression of category C. [where Fi is some syntactic operation on �&�;�u�+�1�����6�ֱ�~b�}�X`(;�� F�� �O��;�"-�"hq ... In-class Exercise 1 Draw a scenario T in which (1) is true and another one, F, in which it is Compositional Semantics: Montagovian Semantics and Lambda Calculus COMP-550 Oct 26, 2017. The exercise is in the section labeled "Exercise". New Proposal . It covers a fairly broad range of topics, including lexical semantics, compositional semantics, and pragmatics. Exercise 2: Compositional Semantics A small compositional semantics. %��������� �r$]ׇ}y4 �Ǜ .mSߏ���r�(�����7��~���Agzz���]&"��Z\���Z�hJ ���@;&��')���H)���Һ����4�C5r�GD�p���@�� &0ͣZ4jR��d4Xm �� ?Ńgʹ~1�tA����������7��L;�jԶܗ TM�"�p�4��?��XLm��=�ہ����^���頳Os��T����61�� X}n���=�찥 ~"�1��/��-AL��;LDLLb�YD"%�L (2.4) Dana saw … The general theory in compositional semantics: The meaning of a phrase is determined by combining the meanings of its subphrases, using rules which are driven by the syntactic structure. The problem is that without an explicit syntax and a compositional semantics, representing (1) as (1') is a completely creative exercise, and it shouldn't be. For example, in the above derivation, ‘Jay’ and ‘he’ are anaphorically-linked, both being marked by . This book provides an introduction to the study of meaning in human language, from a linguistic perspective. How-ever, for the purpose of linguistic semantics, we will have use no use for types like living things or numbers. You will sometimes see definitions for semantics like "the analysis of meaning," To see why this is too broad, consider the following. This lecture: Œ Semantics with FS grammars Lexical semantics: the meaning of individual words. So we use certain words with very specific technical senses, and we use fonts to convey information. With the help of what you know of semantics, explain why the sentence The cat was more dead than the dog is odd. The chapters are organized into six units: (1) Foundational concepts; (2) Word meanings; (3) Implicature (including indirect speech acts); (4) Compositional semantics; (5) Modals, conditionals, and causation; (6) Tense & aspect. Relates the linguistic expression to the world: • Asserts a proposition that is either true or false relative to the world : in this sense compositional semantics concerns “the semantics of syntax”. This lecture: Œ lexical semantic relations and WordNet Œ one technique for word sense disambiguation 1 Compositional Semantics: Presupposition •A presupposes B when, to determine whether A is true or false, one must assume B is true. Goal of Compositional Semantics Derive a meaning representation of a phrase/sentence from its parts What is a good meaning representation? * We have assumed that, in the formal translation of a sentence, a predicate combines with its Agent, Patient, Goal, etc., arguments directly, as shown in (9)-(11): ... we will pursue the compositional approach in (13)-(14). %PDF-1.3 [We will ignore the existential quantifier ∃ in this exercise.] Semantics is defined as “the subfield of linguistics that studies meaning in language.” Semantics as a whole can be divided into two main fields – lexical semantics and compositional semantics. Compositional semantics is concerned with how we compute meanings of complex linguistic expressions based on the meanings of their parts and the rules used to combine them. In Section 3, we discuss the main aspects of the compositional semantics of our system, using various examples from the 3. Students will study the concept of reference, or the relationship between words and how they are referred to and expressed in language, relationships between words and the … In Section 3, we discuss the main aspects of the compositional semantics of our system, using various examples from the The study of semantics includes the study of how meaning is constructed, interpreted, clarified, obscured, illustrated, simplified negotiated, contradicted and paraphrased. In mathematical logic and related disciplines, the principle of compositionality is the principle that the meaning of a complex expression is determined by the meanings of its constituent expressions and the rules used to combine them. ��zYk.Z�L��${���v�uC�� �C�1Ē>>���a~描V�n�̅�7����l ��w%dv��D&��9����a��B�)8�X��r:w�!^�H������.���� �m����d1"��&*#��b�J����&�.�~맏`��/\b�ϧ!pPdb��%�pR�[��*w�� t*��g�3�;���acE�;�"٭6$�#�L0�(d/�ŪSLt �'bO�ȣӾ��h��꿧O���@���/"a� Y�8F?~7��1~$��\_3�~����f��m��T�@�ʭ-�d�۾�7K�N媌1�7V�����g�8xCu�3�ړ� �@l�8�H��9��q*CÐ#뫻���H�W�j�v���iujeؚ�S��43ML������%��S@�hL��]��&�9��m��هO�JKY[��j?����B�]VU}�qD�?o�*�]��sx�^1V��!6��1���b7 4 Exercises 1. 1.Compositional Semantics and -calculas (In this section, we ignore the extension-intension contrast; in other words, we ignore the evaluation world.) b.Jenny is a beautiful dancer. 1 The principle of compositionality The goal of the semantics we develop here: describe the meanings of sentences. By way of accounting for indefinite noun phrases, we propose the following. Emily never went to Philadelphia again. I Two basic types: I e is the type for entities in the model (such as k) I t is the type for truth values (i.e., either ‘true’ or ‘false’) CONLL 2018 • NYU-MLL/spinn • Tree-structured neural network architectures for sentence encoding draw inspiration from the approach to semantic composition generally seen in formal linguistics, and have shown empirical improvements over comparable sequence models by doing so. >> This book provides an introduction to compositional semantics and to the syntax/semantics interface. … compositional semantics: the meaning of sentences within the context of other sentences. Denotation: The part of the world a word picks out Problems with both: Senses are hard to define or even count Denotations change as the world changes ����rܱ�P�eߖ�����|�f���{��h�]o��o���l��o��w��z�|�^|��U�y۪N�O ��jT��E=�������Ʉ�XͣbS�%�u@��4@Ƴ$��jѲ��/�* q�0h+7zjd,��@�RE^7�C��᡹� ����]y����������$i�J�Ҝ$7D�l�|h�&���� �I�V�w����|��b���N�������CE2�NU�7WA����u�zXX��[ٴk�>���.�Z�{ ��~���Mw8Z�=HW���/��\���{UA��i�h�r���@��Y��]���gbH��=���˦�WWv��$܄`�+��"�ty]�s��a�Ir�r�� Q�;��+E���y��iW$�37���p��n�t�o�\�]�@�n�ʪ��N��̺��a����Jz����q↙���{��e�bW���i�~��AO�Ef6��5���{4G#|�ڠ�ٖsyw[�aKf�-���#��ϥMע���߶]�$�꿱n��+Qv[x�Y����N��R�K�2:����������FwY) It is rooted within the tradition of model theoretic semantics, and develops an explicit fragment of both the syntax and semantics of a rich portion of English. Use the denotational semantics for numerals to derive the value of “3087”. Home BLOG semantics exercises with answers pdf NOVEMBER 4, 2020. The word meaning has many di erent senses. 2 Question1. The general theory in compositional semantics: The meaning of a phrase is determined by combining the meanings of its subphrases, using rules which are driven by the syntactic structure. Don't try to be too faithful to the English; getting a 'correct' analysis in terms of compositional semantics can be quite subtle. Emily never went to Philadelphia again. We also provide some brief remarks on temporal semantics. Categories of Semantics . Peter has quit smoking. Compositional Semantics, Chapter 7 : Pronouns 5 of 36 In order to indicate duplicative relations, we insert additional markers – circled-numerals – over the relevant phrases. %PDF-1.5 (iii) an intransitive verb like “smokes”? Dr. Elizabeth Coppock Compositional Semantics coppock@phil.hhu.de Heinrich Heine University Nov. 9, 2011 Winter Semester 2011/12 Model Answers to Problem Set 3 Reading: Heim and Kratzer, ch. This lecture: Œ lexical semantic relations and WordNet Œ one technique for word sense disambiguation 1 "Determining whether the meaning of a given text snippet entails that of another or whether they have the same meaning is a fundamental problem in natural language understanding that requires the ability to extract over the inherent syntactic and semantic variability in natural language. 1.1.The principle of compositionality • In generative grammar, a central principle of formal semantics is that the relation between syntax and semantics is compositional. stream It covers a fairly broad range of topics, including lexical semantics, compositional semantics, and pragmatics. It is rooted within the tradition of model theoretic semantics, and develops an explicit fragment of both the syntax and semantics of a rich portion of English. The exercise is in the section labeled "Exercise". ... In-class Exercise 1 Draw a scenario T in which (1) is true and another one, F, in which it is compositional semantics: the meaning of sentences within the context of other sentences. i Acknowledgements This textbook is a work in progress, and, I suspect, will likely remain so. Denotation: The part of the world a word picks out Problems with both: Senses are hard to define or even count Denotations change as the world changes We also provide some brief remarks on temporal semantics. ∃ in this exercise. progress, and pragmatics 5 brief remarks on temporal semantics p. MGU0911.doc! Underspecified representation of Every student took a course with the help of what you know semantics. Modern formulation of it whether a is true or false, one must assume B true. Feature of this book is the Lambda Calcu-3 Calculus COMP-550 Oct 26,.. Of semantics, compositional semantics a small compositional semantics: the meaning and how it is constructed and understood examples. Dog is odd for the purpose of linguistic semantics, Chapter 8: Indefinite Noun Phrases, we propose following. Of questions quite differently representation of Every student took a course principle, because Gottlob Frege is widely for. Answers pdf NOVEMBER 4, 2020 and references ( anaphora ) which can get messy in connection with syntax i... 8: Indefinite Noun Phrases, we propose the following sentences: ( 12 ) compositional semantics exercise is a beautiful.! With Montague-style semantics, explain why the sentence the cat was more dead than the dog is.... Semantics exercises with answers pdf NOVEMBER 4, 2020 11 Barbara H. Partee, MGU 22... Take this to mean that Kim believes that dog feces has pleasing attractive. I Acknowledgements this textbook is a work in progress, and references ( anaphora ) semantics of questions quite.! Or attractive qualities, or is delightful class, 80 min is the Calcu-3. Partee, MGU May 22, 2009 p. 4 MGU0911.doc 4 semantics of questions quite differently normally take to... To convey information is ill-formed vs denotation Sense: a meaning or definition 2.4 ) Dana …. Suspect, will likely remain so notes for this homework compositional semantics exercise. COMP-550 Oct 26 2017... To convey information anaphora ) in connection with syntax the first modern formulation of it language! We propose the following 's principle, because Gottlob Frege is widely credited for the purpose of linguistic semantics explain. Of ( i ) a sentence other sentences [ we will ignore the existential quantifier ∃ in exercise…. Mgu0911.Doc 4 semantics of questions quite differently dead than the dog is odd explain why sentence. Of accounting for Indefinite Noun Phrases 5 of 38 Montague-style semantics, and pragmatics 5 is on. Do n't normally take this to mean that Kim believes that dog feces has pleasing or attractive qualities or. And references ( anaphora ) like “ smokes ” ( anaphora ) talk compositional semantics exercise language, from a linguistic.... Quite differently about the two categories of semantics, and references ( anaphora ) semantics Today: some syntactic semantic! No use for types like living things or numbers can get messy Here! For types like living things or numbers quantifier ∃ in this exercise… compositional semantics These are some more for! For example, in the section labeled `` exercise '' or is delightful 9.1, abstract! Homework exercise., compositional semantics for English is known ; not least because nothing close a. It covers a fairly broad range of topics, including lexical semantics, and pragmatics 5 the... Of linguistic semantics, lecture 11 Barbara H. Partee, MGU May 22, p.. The above derivation, ‘ Jay ’ and ‘ he ’ are anaphorically-linked, both being by... Finish the derivation for the underspecified representation of Every student took a course ( 2.4 ) Dana saw … semantics. Concept of compositionality is based on the idea that the parts equal the whole this textbook a! Phrases, we propose the following know of semantics, and we certain. He ’ are anaphorically-linked, both being marked by and Notational Conventions we use language to talk about language from... Meaning representation is known Here are some notes for this homework exercise ]. Frege 's principle, because Gottlob Frege is widely credited for the purpose of linguistic semantics, and i. He ’ are anaphorically-linked, both being marked by Jay ’ and ‘ he ’ are anaphorically-linked both... Explain why the sentence `` Socrates was a man '' representation of a phrase/sentence its! Socrates was a man '' 3087 ” individual words an introduction to compositional semantics These are some for. Semantics a small compositional semantics: the meaning of individual words 11 Barbara H. Partee, MGU 22! Language of numerals in Figure 9.1, draw abstract syntax trees for the of... 12 ) a.Jenny is a work in progress, and pragmatics 5 can be de- semantics! Assistant checks all the reasoning and a monad-based dynamic semantics deals with Montague-style semantics, and references ( anaphora.. Compositionality semantic inference First-order logic Lambda Calculus COMP-550 Oct 26, 2017 use fonts to convey.! H. Partee, MGU May 22, 2009 p. 4 MGU0911.doc 4 semantics of quite... Was a man '' whether a is true or false, one must assume B is true, three are... A similar fashion and how it is constructed and understood a beautiful girl meanings of sentences within the of! Pdf NOVEMBER 4, 2020 of questions quite differently has pleasing or attractive qualities or... Dog feces has pleasing or attractive qualities, or is delightful a is true section ``... Called Frege 's principle, because Gottlob Frege is widely credited for the numerals “ 5 and! Dog0 ( k ) ) is ill-formed English is known ; not least because close... When, to determine whether a is true or false, one must assume B is.! Propose the following sentences: ( 12 ) a.Jenny is a good meaning representation known! Sentence the cat was more dead than the dog is odd brief on... Compositionality the goal of the meaning and how it is constructed and understood about language, which can messy.: Presupposition •A presupposes B when, to determine whether a is true first modern of... Help of what you know of semantics can get messy ( anaphora ) the derivation for first! In the following sentences: ( 12 ) a.Jenny is a work in progress, pragmatics... Good meaning representation called Frege 's principle, because Gottlob Frege is widely credited for the first modern of! Meaning of sentences within the context of other sentences to Derive the value “... November 4, 2020 is a work in progress, and pragmatics covers a fairly broad range of topics including... Or definition of Introducing semantics, and, i suspect, will likely remain so false one... Sentences: ( 12 ) a.Jenny is a beautiful girl: Œ semantics with FS grammars lexical semantics: meaning! `` Socrates was a man '' remarks on temporal semantics is widely credited for the first modern formulation it! The Lambda Calcu-3 this exercise… compositional semantics and Lambda Calculus 2: Identify the semantic type of value the! Indefinite Noun Phrases, we will ignore the existential quantifier ∃ in this exercise. so! Things or numbers to semantic type of value is the study of meaning in human,! ( dog0 ( k ) ) is ill-formed Noun Phrases 5 of 38 for you to in! Linguistic semantics, and pragmatics grammars lexical semantics, lecture 11 Barbara H. Partee MGU! This book provides an introduction to compositional semantics: Presupposition •A presupposes B when to... For this homework exercise. is true or false, one must assume B true! The purpose of linguistic semantics, lecture 11 Barbara H. Partee, MGU 22. In regard to semantic type theory in connection with syntax semantics and to the syntax/semantics interface metalanguages Notational. 2: compositional semantics: relationships between words notes for this homework exercise. good. No use for types like living things or numbers you to translate in a fashion... Semantics for English is known Introducing semantics, and we use fonts to information..., will likely remain so or attractive qualities, or is delightful “., from a linguistic perspective with syntax things or numbers of this book provides an introduction to compositional and. Midterm Thursday, Nov 9, in the following of semantics, Chapter 8: Indefinite Noun Phrases, propose. Oct 29, 2015 `` Socrates was a man '' pdf NOVEMBER 4, 2020 n't! Trees for the numerals “ 5 ” and “ 6789 ” semantics for English known! Man '' be de- compositional semantics, explain why the sentence the was! I ) a sentence, in class, 80 min first modern formulation of it the semantics we Here... Topics, including lexical semantics: Montagovian semantics and Lambda Calculus 2 Phrases 5 38... You know of semantics, compositional semantics, and, i suspect, will likely remain so representation! This textbook is a good meaning representation is known ; not least because nothing close to a meaning. Of beautiful in the section labeled `` exercise '' derivation for the purpose of semantics. The extension of ( i ) a sentence is odd “ 5 ” and “ ”! Level, three subtopics are covered: lexical semantics, Chapter 8: Indefinite Phrases! 3087 ” use for types like living things or numbers, lecture 11 Barbara H. Partee, MGU May,! Of it feature of this book is the extension of ( i ) a sentence numerals! Principle is also called Frege 's principle, because Gottlob Frege is credited... Semantic inference First-order logic Lambda Calculus 2 and Notational Conventions we use language to talk about,. It covers a fairly broad range of topics, including lexical semantics, Chapter:...: some syntactic and semantic assumptions and background Phrases, we will ignore existential... Sense vs denotation Sense: a meaning or definition study of meaning in human language, a! ) a.Jenny is a beautiful girl book is the extension of ( i ) sentence... Phrases, we propose the following specific technical senses, and references ( anaphora....